This heavy-weight competition would be a fierce battle between two prominent contenders – Pelican vs Yeti Coolers.

When it comes to choosing from some of the top cooler brands available on the market, most buyers find it difficult picking between Pelican and Yeti Coolers. With these two prominent brands competing for the heavyweight title, it leads us to think “What cooler is better?

Now since most consumers tend to will ask which one is better? We took our time to test and compare Pelican vs Yeti coolers to come up with this comparison review. Many factors have been taken into consideration, e.g. price, Ice retention and portability to name a few.

Pelican vs Yeti Coolers – Pelican Coolers 2017

 Pelican Pro Gear Yeti Tundra Cooler
ImagePelican Cooler WhiteClosed yeti tundra cooler
Price Check Price
Check Price
Capacity20 - 250 Quarts28 -322 Quarts
Largest Dimensions15” x 10.5” x 10”
62” x 27” x 29”
WarrantyLifetime Warranty5 Years Warranty
BuildRotomolded Rotomolded

Logo of Yeti   Pelican Banner - best ice chests 2016

Just to have a hint of some of the things that will be answered in this review, check the synopsis below:

  • What are the best coolers for both Pelican and Yeti brands?
  • How do Pelican coolers compare to Yeti coolers?
  • Which cooler is worth the money?

So, let’s get started right away!

Pelican is known for manufacturing high-performance cooling products that are extremely durable. They’ve been in the industry since 1976 and have carved a reputation and a name for themselves.

As one of YETI competitors, the Pelican prides itself in its high ice retention capability that can go up to 10 days, made possible through the thickest insulation of coolers in the industry.
The coolers come with locking latches that help keep the contents cold for longer, and a life time warranty to make it a favorite amongst hunters.

Pelican ProGear Elite Cooler

Pelican Cooler - heavy duty cooler

This is perhaps the best Pelican cooler for the money, out of the wide range of options available. This cooler is particularly a favorite among most outdoor adventure lovers for it’s easy to manage size and capacity.

It can keep the contents frozen for up to 10 days as it comes with a freezer grade gasket and a 2-inch polyurethane insulation.

Furthermore, it has a dual handle system, that is, hinged and molded-in types of handles for easier carrying. The latches are the press and pull type and are wide enough to allow gloved use.

Pelican offers up to 7 color variants to choose your favourite color from. You can choose from dark blue, light blue, marine white, OD green, orange, outdoor tan and purple.

Pros
  • Longer ice retention period of up to 10 days.
  • Bear resistant certification for longer durability.
  • Stainless steel hardware that is resistant from corrosion.
  • Extensive choice of colors.
Cons

The major issue with the Pelican coolers is that they are oversized and are relatively bulkier as compared to Yeti coolers.

Sizes and Dimensions

If you are after size varieties, then Pelican coolers delivers a variety of quart capacities. You will also get a vaired color-scheme to choose from. There are smaller Pelican coolers with sizes as little as 20 quarts to large sized capacities of up to 250 quarts.

Regardless of the size, you are after, you can always be sure of one thing- they are all of the same high quality.

Check out the following table on the different Pelican coolers according to their capacities.

Quart capacity
Ice RetentionWeightDimension
20 Quarts
Up to 10 days
16 lbs
21” x 15” x 16”
35 Quarts 7-10 days
32.3 lbs
26.4” x 20” x 18.8”
45 Quarts 7-10 days
36 lbs
29.7” x 20” x 19.2”
65 Quarts
7-10 days
48 lbs
37.2” x 20” x 19.8”
95 QuartsUp to 10 days
57.9 lbs
39” x 26” x 21”
150 Quarts
7-10 days
66 lbs
45.2” x 25.8” x 25.2”
250 Quarts
Up to 10 days
111 lbs62” x 27” x 29”

Materials and design

Pelican Elite ProGear Coolers are built using the rotomolding process and the materials used ensure that the cooler is resistant from all types of attack and mishandling.
It comes with the thickest wall insulations that are proven to retain ice for a period of up to 10 days. The cooler comes with a freezer grade gasket that has a polyurethane insulation thickness of 2 inches.

It is fitted with special locking latches, folding handles and wide wheels for the soft or rugged terrain. Every cooler comes with a pair of handles, one under the lid while the other is rather a molded flush mounted set.

Pelican vs Yeti Coolers – Yeti Coolers 2017

There’s no doubt that Yeti is one of the top cooler brands available on the market today. YETI is known for their large spectrum of coolers ranging from the soft-sided Yeti Hopper to the Yeti Tundra.

Yeti Tundra 45

Pelican vs Yeti coolers - Closed yeti tundra cooler

The Yeti Tundra series actually has a wide range bear-proof coolers with varying sizes ranging from 35 quarts to 420 quarts.

If you like camping out on your own or with a small group, then Yeti Tundra 45 is an excellent choice for you.

As part of the Pelican vs Yeti coolers comparison, the Yeti Tundra coolers are highly resistant to any form of mishandling as they are built using a rotomolding design.

Its ColdLock gasket minimizes entry of air into the cooler thus keeping your beverages and foods chilled for long.

Pros
  • They are fitted with an easy drain plug for easier drainage of melted ice.
  • They are rotomolded for an extended durability.
  • Have a vortex drainage system to keep the outer core dry.
  • Warranty covers every component of the cooler.
Cons
  • Yeti coolers are more pricey.

Size and dimension

Yeti Tundra coolers have varying sizes.

Check out the tables below for the different models and sizes:

Model Dimension (LWH)
Capacity Weight
Tundra 35
15” x 10.5” x 10”
28 Quarts
20 lbs
Tundra 45
19.5” x 10.5” x 10”
37 Quarts
23 lbs
Tundra 50
18” x 12” x 12.125”
46 Quarts
26 lbs
Tundra 65
24.5” x 12” x 10.125”
56 Quarts
29 lbs
Tundra 75
27.25” x 14” x 12”
79 Quarts
34 lbs
Tundra 105
24.5” x 14” x 14.25”
84 Quarts
36 lbs
Tundra 110
31” x 12.5” x 13.75”
92 Quarts
39 lbs
Tundra 125
38” x 16” x 20”
100 Quarts
49 lbs
Tundra 160
45” x 19.5” x 21.5”
150 Quarts
54 lbs
Tundra 250
47” x 15” x 21.25”
232 Quarts
70 lbs
Tundra 350
63.25” x 24.5” x 3.25”
322 Quarts
92 lbs

Material and design

Pelican vs yeti coolers - closed

Yeti Tundra Coolers are built with a rotomolded shell for an outstanding performance when it comes to withstanding mishandling that occurs during transportation or from bear attacks. It’s been certified to be bear proof and several tests have been conducted to prove that it can withstand the test of time.

The cooler has a somewhat smoother edge and surfaces that make it easier to clean. With a whitewater raft like construction, these coolers are suitable for the long haul as they are considered as one of the coolers with the best form of insulation. Despite having a relatively lower ice retention capability as compared to Pelican, Yeti Tundra series of coolers are excellent performers.

Pelican vs Yeti Coolers – Side by side comparison

With very many excellent features you can choose from, you really won’t get it wrong when you go for either Pelican or Yeti coolers. It will all boil down to your personal preferences, but just in case you are getting started, we will help you arrive at an informed decision with ease. Let’s consider some of the features that you’d want to have a look at when about to make a decision.

Design

In terms of design, both coolers are excellently designed to provide outstanding performance. Yeti Tundra Series of coolers are fashioned using a high-quality rotomolded construction, permafrost insulation, and a non-sweat design which makes the cooler’s outer core dry.
It also features a vortex type of draining system to make the draining process much easier. These coolers also have a double haul handle made from polyester rope of military grade.

On Pelican’s end, it’s also built using the rotomolding construction with a freezer grade gasket so the contents of the cooler can remain chilled for days. The hardware is a stainless steel type for corrosion resistance and features press and pull latches. While Yeti coolers are fitted with rope handles, Pelican gave a molded-in bar handles.

Each of the cooler brands are built for a longer lasting duration with a tough body that can withstand all mishandling during transportation, lifting or bear attacks!

Warranty

Ice Retention

Different cooler sizes

This is the biggest determinant when it comes to choosing the best cooler out of the two brands.

According to the manufacturer, Yeti Tundra can hold ice for an extended period of time. But what consumers really want is what the users say about their retention capacity.

As for Pelican, the ice retention capability of the coolers is a little longer than that of Yeti Tundra.

The manufacturer says that ice can be retained in the cooler for a period of up to 10 days. Just like with the user experience from Yeti Tundra users, let’s have a look at some of the feedbacks from users of Pelican.

Generally, Pelican can retain the ice for an average of about 6 to 10 days, meaning that the manufacturer’s claim is true. In this category, Pelican takes the lead.

Durability

In terms of durability, numerous tests have been carried out on each of the cooler brands and both gave a tremendous performance. They are certified to be bear proof as several tests have been performed with bears who tried to crush these ice chests without success.

In conclusion, each is equally durable and can be an excellent choice when going out in the wild o hunt or camp.

Pelican vs Yeti coolers – The bottom line

Yeti Marine Cooler - best ice chests 2016

Just like we’ve seen in the Pelican vs Yeti coolers review, both coolers are tied in almost every category considered.

Therefore, when it comes to choosing the most suitable and functional cooler between these two brands, it will all come down to your personal preferences.
But you might want to include factors such as pricing, ice retention and warranty as major determining factors.

Taking these two major factors into account the Pelican cooler takes the lead for its more affordable price and its lifetime warranty.

The Pelican and Yeti coolers have both made it to the best coolers of 2017. There isn’t much difference between Yeti and Pelican coolers but issues such as warranty are very different.

The handles of each may also form a point of preference. Again, it will mainly depend on what you want, but whichever choice you make, you can never go wrong with either of these coolers.